How the DBD provides greater certainty

One of the key advantages offered by the DBD is greater protection from the effects of poor investment market performance, as occurred during the Global Financial Crisis (GFC). Here we illustrate how the respective benefits of a DBD member and an Accumulation 2 member would have been impacted by investment performance over 10 years beginning 1 July 2007.

July 2007: Rob and Nick are UniSuper members with a lot in common

They have the same annual salary

Line graph showing a salary of $100,000 per year with 5% growth each year. Text version linked below. 

View text version

They are the same age

Rob and Nick are both 45 years old.

They receive the same super contributions

Graph showing Rob and Nick's salary consisting of 17% before-tax employer super contributions and 7% after-tax employee super contributions.

And have the same retirement savings

$350,000

However they have different super products


Rob is a unisuper Defined benefit division member of 15 years. Formula-based benefits, based on salary and years of service. The main advantage of the DBD is a cost-effective smoothing of investment returns achieved through collective risk-sharing. Nick is an Accumulation 2 (A2) member invested in the Balanced option. Accumulation 2 members have market-based benefits, determined by a number of potential investment options covering a range of sectors and risk categories.

July 2016: A 10-year review of Rob and Nick’s benefits

Steady growth

The darker blue line shows Rob’s total benefit under the DBD as the DB formula delivers an improving benefit based on rising salary, age and years of service. Even during an extreme market downturn over 2008-2009, Rob experienced no reduction to his benefit.

Mirroring the markets

The light blue line shows Nick’s benefit as an Accumulation 2 member. Over the 10 year period, the value of Nick’s benefit was more volatile. During the GFC over 2008-2009, Nick’s benefit fell even with ongoing contributions. As the market recovered, Nick’s benefit improved to a similar level as Rob’s benefit.


Line graph showing Rob and Nicks benefits over 10 years. Text version linked below.

View text version

A 10-year period, which encompassed the GFC, has been chosen to illustrate that the DBD can provide members with a greater degree of certainty than an accumulation-style benefit, which can be quite volatile. For some members this greater certainty may be very important, particularly as they approach retirement. If we were to consider different periods, the results could be very different from those indicated above. Difference results could also arise depending on the profile of the particular member (age, salary and service length) and the accumulation investment option selected.

Protection and predictability

Using actual investment returns, the graph above shows two key DBD strengths when compared with an accumulation-style benefit:

Protection from investment market downturns

With the pooling of assets across the DBD membership, the DBD can provide benefits that are not directly subject to volatile market movements. Even during the GFC, one of the worst economic downturns in recent history, DBD benefits were paid in full.

Increased ability to predict future benefits

Unlike an Accumulation arrangement, DBD members can better plan for their retirement as defined benefits are based on a salary-based formula and are not directly exposed to investment market downturns.